Nick Montesano
← All work

OneTrust · UX Designer

Disclosure Approval Experience

Approvers who review once or twice a year got lost. They got a view of their own.

Redesigned approver view

Impact

90%

user satisfaction with the new approver view

Post-launch survey

11

approver interviews across 5 customer organizations, plus a survey sent to 40 customers. Every insight became a fix: first-visit guidance, a context side panel and a next-task list.

3 of 3 insights shipped

  • Separated the approver and respondent views, so approvers only see what they act on
  • Added guidance and a next-task list for people who review once or twice a year
  • Kept product and engineering aligned when customer research stalled

Overview

Problem

Approvers used the same screens as the employees filling forms out.

What I did

Led research and design for a dedicated approver view.

Result

90% satisfaction after launch. Shipped on time.

Team · Time

2 designers, researcher, 2 PMs, 2 eng leads. 3 months.

The problem

One screen, two different jobs.

Employees answer ethics questions; approvers review and approve or send back. Both used one interface.

“When there are so many things to look at, they can lose sight of the most important things.”Interview participant
Original approver screens
Before: hidden entry arrows and a redundant question navigator.

Research

Talk to approvers, then test the fix.

11 interviews across 5 customer organizations, plus a survey sent to 40 customers. When responses slowed over the holidays, I shifted to technical discovery with PMs and engineering to keep the sprint moving.

Research process: planning, internal interviews, customer survey, customer interviews, synthesis
Planning → internal interviews → customer survey → customer interviews → synthesis.

Finding 1 · Infrequent users get lost

Guide them in.

Finding

Many approvers review once or twice a year.

Fix

A tip modal they can turn off; respondent-only features removed.

Welcome tip modal over the approver view
First-visit guidance that stays out of the way.

Finding 2 · Context lives elsewhere

Bring context to the review.

Finding

Approvers left the platform to look things up.

Fix

A side panel with HR data and disclosure history.

Finding 3 · “Now what?”

Always show the next task.

Finding

After submitting, approvers didn’t know what was next.

Fix

Redirect to a prioritized task list.

Disclosure task list with pending and completed approvals
What’s left, and what’s done.

The pivot · Text over charts

Accuracy beat visualization.

Chose

A dense, structured text layout.

Rejected

The planned data-viz dashboard.

Why

Approvers valued accuracy; the design system had no flexible charts.

Cost

Less at-a-glance summary; ~2 sprints saved.

Design tradeoff: dashboard concept versus text layout

User feedback · Positive, yet constructive

Testing shaped the final details.

Customers found the new view clearer and easier to use. Their concerns went straight into the final design.

Tested approver view with positive customer quotes123456
  1. “Very minimalistic and to the point.”
  2. “Heaps better! You can see all of the questions easily.”
  3. “Love the employee summary…[and] the date submitted.”
  4. “…this UI, is simpler, and easier to digest…”
  5. “I like how the comment shows up right there.”
  6. “The sidebar with information is valuable.”
What worked: a simpler, scannable view and context in the side panel.
Tested approver view with constructive customer quotes1234
  1. “Rethink ‘Submit approval’ language… like ‘Finish review’…”
  2. “I’m not sure what value the number on the left… provides… kind of confusing.”
  3. “Displaying email address is critical.”
  4. “I’m curious if we will be able to pull [additional] information…”
What changed: “Submit approval” became “Finish review,” and question numbers were removed.

From my manager

“Nick is a skilled and thorough researcher… His ability to uncover key user insights has contributed significantly to the success of our team’s projects.”John Langford · UX Manager, OneTrust

What I’d do differently

  1. Plan research around the calendar. The customer survey stalled over the December holidays, and I had to pivot to internal discovery. Next time I’d start recruiting earlier and line up backup participants
  2. Measure behavior, not just sentiment. 90% satisfaction shows approvers liked the view. Time to approve and fewer send-backs would show whether the bottleneck actually moved